We have conducted a field efficacy trial evaluating the efficacy of 14 biological insecticides alone or as a tank mix against lepidopteran pests, including diamondback moth (DBM), beet armyworm(BAW), and cabbage looper (CL). The insect pressures were relatively low when we initiated the insecticide applications; the CL number was never high enough to be considered for statistical analysis and treatment comparisons.

We applied all insecticides at the highest label rate when sprayed alone or at mid-rate when sprayed as a mixture of two insecticides using an application volume of 40 gal/ac. The adjuvant, Oroboost, was added to each of the insecticide treatments at a rate of 0.4% v/v. Most of the insecticides evaluated in our trial are registered for lepidopteran control except for M-Pede, BotaniGard, and PFR-97.

The results of our trial showed that Xentari, Xentari + Pyganic, and Entrust provided the highest level of BAW suppression. We also found that other insecticides/mixes, including Aza-Direct, Dipel, Dipel +Pyganic, Gargoil, Grandevo, Venerate, M-Pede, and PFR-97, may also cause some levels of BAW suppression (Figure 1A). Xentari and Dipel + Pyganic provided the best DBM suppression, followed by Xentari + Pyganic, Dipel, and Entrust, which provided 50-60% of DBM suppression (Figure 1B). Pyganic alone did not control either BAW or DBM (Figure 1A&B).

Table 1. List of bioinsecticides evaluated


Figure 1. Means Beet armyworm larvae (A) and Diamondback moth (B) per cabbage plant as affected by bioinsecticide sprays.