Question to IPM team:
I applied Raptor and Pursuit to an alfalfa field. Can you provide some information on the carryover and phytotoxicity to onions?
IPM Team:      We haven’t done plant back evaluations with these products. The soil persistence that is mentioned in the AZ PCA study guide is 2-4 months for the Raptor and 3-12 months for Pursuit. The label specifies longer replanting intervals for various crops and suggests that “before planting any crop not listed elsewhere in Rotational Crop Restrictions, a successful field bioassay must be completed. The field bioassay consists of a test strip of the intended rotational crop planted across the previously treated field and grown to maturity”.
An interesting journal article “Injury to Vegetable Crops from Herbicides Applied in Previous Years”, mentions In 1995, residual imazethapyr delayed tomato maturity but did not reduce tomato yield. Other vegetable crops were not injured by herbicide residues. Then in 1997 “imazethapyr carryover injured cabbage, onion, and tomato plants and reduced tomato yield most injury occurred at 2X and 4X rates¹.
The “Carrington Research Center in NDSU did an herbicide carryover study included here which presents the “response of onions to herbicides applied to soybean the previous year²” including Raptor and Pursuit.  Also, in this study (table below) onion injury was significant in the 2X and 4X rates.

Another “Evaluation of Pre and Post Emergence Herbicides on Yield Contributing and Quality Characters in Onion” found that “Imazethapyr @ 100 g a.i / ha as post emergence application (20 DAT) coupled with preemergence herbicides produced the lower (yield) values than weedy check as Imazethapyr found to be toxic to the Onion^3”.
The field study “Efficacy of imidazolinone herbicides applied to imidazolinone resistant maize and their carryover effect on rotational crops” showed sensitivity of rotational crops, from high to low, was the following: Beta vulgaris>Capsicum annum>Lycopersicum esculentum>Cucumis melo>Hordeum vulgare>Medicago sativa>Lolium multiflorum>Avena sativa>Pisum sativum>Allium cepa (onion)>Zea mays.
The label’s recommendation of doing a bioassay is very useful. Many factors can affect herbicide carryover and every case is different. Low soil moisture might not permit appropriate soil conditions for an efficient microbiological and chemical degradation of imidazolinone herbicides³. Other elements to consider are the soil texture, pH, soil temperature, microbial activity, photodegradation, previous crop, water applied after application of the herbicide, soil tillage intensity. The combinations of these elements could contribute to dissipation of these products. Also, having this information would help us determine the best IPM strategy.
 



References:

1. Greenland RG. Injury to vegetable crops from herbicides applied in previous years. Weed Technology. 2003;17(1):73-78. doi:10.1614/0890-037X(2003)017[0073:ITVCFH]2.0.CO;2
2. Herbicide Carryover Study, 1997 Richard Greenland
3. Evaluation of Pre and Post Emergence Herbicides on Yield Contributing and Quality Characters in Onion cv. N-53 M. Venkateswara Reddy* , K. Umajyothi, P. Syam Sundar Reddy and K. Sasikala
4. Efficacy of imidazolinone herbicides applied to imidazolinoneresistant maize and their carryover effect on rotational crops C. Alister1 , M. Kogan